The most profitable mobile communication plan. Tariffs with per-second billing: obvious benefits. Video: Comparison of tariffs without a monthly fee with unexpected conclusions

The FAS proposes to prohibit operators from charging per minute, that is, rounding the duration of a call up. Analysts point out that mobile operators pay their subscribers mainly by the minute, and each other by the second.

Your suggestions regarding the ban per minute billing FAS sent it to the Ministry of Telecom and Mass Communications. According to the antimonopoly plan, the rule should apply to both mobile and fixed line. The idea is to relieve the subscriber from having to pay for the unused part of the minute, that is, in essence, for a service not provided by the operator. This is how Deputy Head of the FAS Anatoly Golomolzin sees the situation.

According to VTB Capital, Due to the adoption of new rules, the revenue of fixed-line operators may decrease by 5%, cellular operators by 10%.

Operators began to actively offer tariffs with per-minute payment instead of per-second, after in 2006 in Russia, at the legislative level, fees for incoming calls were abolished. “Please note that this event did not affect the operators’ revenue that year. This means that they found ways to compensate for losses,” says Ilya Fedotov, head of the stock market analysis department at Veles Capital Investment Company. By 2008, as the site reported, operators had almost completely abandoned per-second payments for intranet intercity calls.

Now, according to the Rustelecom and IKS-Consulting agencies, there are not many tariffs with per-second billing; they are mostly used by operators in those regions where the company has a weak position, and the percentage of users of such tariffs is common base operators is small. The operators themselves prefer to make payments among themselves in seconds, analysts emphasize.

Surprisingly, representatives of the Big Three have conflicting information regarding the methodology for mutual settlements. MegaFon answers: as for calls within Russia, settlements between operators are carried out minutely; in roaming this may be a different period of time, depending on the settings of the partner operator.

Beeline says, that according to the rules of connection, inter-operator settlements are carried out second by second. MTS confirms this and refers to Russian Government Decree No. 161 of March 28, 2005. But according to Ilya Fedotov, normative base, including the specified document, does not provide an unambiguous concept of the mutual accounting system. In his opinion, the situation when an operator pays a lot of its subscribers by the minute, and with another operator by the second, is abnormal.

Beeline fundamentally disagrees with this, they say that there is no “swindle” here. “Firstly, we also have plans with per-second billing and the subscriber himself chooses what to use, and secondly, per-minute billing is really beneficial for subscribers, because it gives discounts and bonuses to active multi-talking subscribers,” says Beeline ". - Unless, of course, you are a pensioner in the Russian outback, who spends 30-40 rubles a month on communications. But just for this category of subscribers it is possible to connect to a per-second plan."

Analysts have a note the profitability of per-minute tariffs makes me smile. "This is perhaps too strong a word. It’s just that long-talking subscribers don’t particularly feel the loss from rounding up to big side, unlike the same pensioners,” says IKS-Consulting analyst Maxim Savvatin.

Most analysts agree on the fact that the FAS attack towards operators is a continuation of the fight for cheap communication, which the country's leadership began with demands to review roaming tariffs. Experts say these proposals are not new and have received renewed attention due to the upcoming elections. There is also an opinion that with such measures FAS officials are trying to increase their “weight”.

Select the fragment with the error text and press Ctrl+Enter

Payment today mobile communications has become as natural, unconditional and regular an expense item as utility bills. On the market cellular communications There are four leading telecommunications operators in Russia: MegaFon, MTS, Beeline and Tele2. Their billboards scream about the most profitable and almost free communication. By the way, iKS-Consalting recognized the cost of mobile communications in Russia as one of the lowest compared to the other 20 countries covered in the study European countries. average cost The tariff package is named around 300 rubles, and the main pricing factor is the volume of Internet traffic.

Tariffs of telecom operators are very dynamic. They reflect company strategy, consumer preferences and industry trends. They operate in parallel with the current ones archived tariffs until the subscriber switches to a new one price offer. It’s not difficult to get lost in such diversity. A comparison of the Big Four's flagship service packages is presented below (1).

Which mobile tariff should I choose?

Due to the constant expansion of the capabilities of our gadgets, it is rational to offer subscribers tariff packages that combine several services (for example, voice communication, SMS messages and mobile Internet). It is more convenient and cheaper for subscribers to purchase a range of services, and operators can earn money on services not included in the subscription fee. Tariff packages are differentiated by the number of included services, by their limit (GB, free minutes, number of SMS) and the needs of the subscriber (mobile Internet, calls on the home network, roaming, etc.). All this determines the cost of the packages.

It should be noted that there is no universal or ideal tariff. Everything is determined by the subscriber’s goals: the subscriber uses mobile Internet more often or voice calls, more often calls the numbers of his operator or other telecom players, uses long-distance or international roaming etc. Therefore, choosing the optimal mobile tariff, you need to understand what benefits you expect from it.

Comparison of tariffs of Russian mobile operators

Mobile tariffs of VimpelCom PJSC (Beeline brand)

Beeline in the “Everything” line offers subscribers five sets of tariffs starting from 300 rubles. up to 1,800 rub. The packages are convenient because they are valid not only in the home network, but also in the regions of Russia under the same conditions without additional payment within the limit. Calls within your network are included in the subscription fee and are not limited. The call limit to other operators is determined by the tariff conditions. Tariffs for international communications are set separately as part of the roaming policy.

Table 1 – Package tariffs of the Beeline operator

Mobile communication tariffs of MegaFon PJSC

The MegaFon operator also offers its subscribers five combinations of tariff packages starting from 250 rubles. up to 2,000 rub. per month. Tariff fees relevant both in the home region and throughout Russia. The volume of calls within your network in your home region is unlimited, which cannot be said about long-distance calls to MegaFon. In two budget packages (All Inclusive XS and All Inclusive S tariffs), the limit on minutes included in the subscription fee also applies to calls to MegaFon outside your home region. Despite the name of the tariff plans, all services are included only in the L and VIP packages. In the rest, according to the terms of the tariff, long-distance calls and SMS to other operators are paid in addition to the monthly subscription fee. Tariffs for international communications are set separately as part of the roaming policy.

Table 2 – Package tariffs of the MegaFon operator

Mobile communication tariffs of MTS PJSC

The MTS tariff family is called SMART and is differentiated into five packages costing from 250 rubles. up to 1,000 rub. per month. Calls to MTS numbers in Russia are included in the subscription fee and are unlimited on all tariffs, except SMART mini. Within SMART mini, unlimited applies only to home network operator, and for long-distance roaming when calling to MTS, the cost per minute is 2 rubles. The terms of the tariff plans remain the same throughout Russia. It is noteworthy that minutes, SMS and Internet traffic unused during the month within the limit are saved and transferred to the next month. Tariffs for international communications are set separately as part of the roaming policy.

Table 3 – Package tariffs of the MTS operator

Mobile tariffsTele2

The price range of tariff packages of the Tele2 operator varies from 240 rubles. up to 600 rub. per month. One of the tariffs, namely “My Tele2”, provides for a daily subscription fee, which does not include packages of minutes and SMS messages. The uniqueness of the operator’s offers lies in the fact that minutes, SMS and GB unused within the package limit are not burned, as in the MTS policy, and also in the fact that visiting social networks(VKontakte, Facebook, Odnoklassiniki), WhatsApp and Viber does not consume limited internet traffic. Tariffs for international communications are set separately as part of the roaming policy.

Table 4 – Package tariffs of the operator “Tele2”

Comparative characteristics of mobile communication tariffs of cellular operators

As already mentioned, the profitability of a tariff for a particular subscriber is determined by the purpose of its connection. Therefore, to determine the best one, it is necessary to take main criterion comparing a specific service.

If we compare the most budget tariff plans of operators, then their monthly subscription fee is approximately equal. The most low price Tele2 differs from the highest cost budget package by only 60 rubles. From the point of view of minutes and Internet traffic limits, the Beeline offer looks most attractive. But it’s worth considering that the minutes included in the subscription fee only apply to calls to all operators within your home region. In addition, MTS and Tele2 carry over the unspent limit to the next month, which may increase the indicators presented in Table 5.

Table 5 – Comparison of the Big Four budget tariff plans

Let's consider the terms of tariff packages. Which operators position as a “best seller”. Tele2 does not report the most popular tariff. The “My Tele2” tariff is now positioned as a flagship offer.

Table 6 - Comparison of popular tariff plans of the Big Four

In addition to package offers, cellular operators provide tariffs without a subscription fee. They are beneficial for those who rarely use or do not use any service at all (for example, mobile Internet). MTS and Beeline offer per-second billing. MegaFon and Tele2 – per minute. A comparison of tariffs without a subscription fee is shown in Table 7.

Table 7 - Comparative characteristics of per-minute tariffs of the Big Four

Mobile Internet: which tariff to choose? Comparative characteristics of tariff plans for mobile Internet from cellular operators

Increase your internet traffic within package offer or connecting to mobile Internet within the tariff without a monthly fee is possible using mobile Internet as a separate service. The Big Four's offerings are reflected in the tables below.

Table 8 – Mobile Internet tariffs from MTS

Table 9 – Mobile Internet tariffs from MegaFon

Table 10 – Mobile Internet tariffs from Tele2

Table 11 – Mobile Internet tariffs from Beeline

All telecom operators, with the exception of MegaFon, have a maximum traffic offer of 30 GB/month. They, like any other limit, can be increased for a fee. MTS and Beeline have premium tariff plans with unlimited night time. The MTS operator also offers the service " Unified Internet", which connects up to 5 devices per additional fee 100 rub./month. For users of several gadgets, this is more profitable than purchasing traffic for each device separately. Most tariffs from all operators can be used within long-distance roaming. MTS charges an additional subscription fee for this. The policy of Tele2 and Beeline allows you to use mobile Internet throughout Russia under the same conditions as in your home region. MegaFon charges intercity roaming in accordance with the terms of the subscriber's current tariff plan.

Mobile communications on the way to 6G".

1 - Information on tariffs was taken from the official websites of cellular operators and is relevant as of April 2017 for subscribers of St. Petersburg and Leningrad Region. Depending on the region, tariff conditions may differ from those presented.

Per second billing – The best decision for those who are not used to long conversations on the phone, but prefer to communicate clearly and to the point. If the connection duration lasts about 30 seconds, then you can significantly save on calls, since this tariff eliminates rounding to minutes. Connection additional functions will provide profitable terms For sending SMS and use of mobile Internet.

Description of the "Per-second" tariff 2018

For subscribers who like to talk on the phone for a long time, this tariff package will not work, since for one minute of conversation 3 rubles will be charged, which is an expensive pleasure for local calls. The cost of outgoing calls to numbers of any operators within the home region is 0.05 rubles per second. Payment for subscriber service and there are no incoming calls. Calls begin to be charged only from a third of a second of connection.

IN different regions rates may vary slightly. IN in this case The tariff is considered using the example of the Moscow region and the region.

• Subscription fee - 0 rubles.
• The cost of switching to the tariff is 0 rubles

Communication in the home region

All incoming calls, as usual, will be free for the subscriber, but outgoing calls to the numbers of all operators in the home region will cost 3 rubles per minute.

Long distance communication

When making calls within Russia, all outgoing calls to numbers of any operators will cost 3.9 rubles per minute, but do not forget that the Kyivstar operator is still operating in Crimea, calls to it will cost 12 rubles per minute, and to others' numbers Ukrainian operators in Crimea, 24 rubles per minute will be charged per minute of conversation.

International communications

It will not cost much to make outgoing calls to Beeline numbers in the CIS countries and Georgia - 12 rubles per minute. At the same time, outgoing calls to numbers of other operators in the CIS countries will cost twice as much (24 rubles/min). You can call to Europe, the USA and Canada for 35 rubles per minute.

Messages

When activating the "My SMS" service, you can send free messages, but only in the home region.

Mobile Internet on tariff

The Internet on this tariff plan cannot be called cheap - the cost of 1 MB is 9.95 rubles.

That's why active users For mobile Internet, it is recommended to activate the “Highway” option, after which 1 MB will be provided free of charge.

How to activate the "Per-second" tariff?

If previous tariff plan was connected more than a month ago, then no money is debited for the transition; in other cases, the cost of connecting to the “Per Second” tariff will be 150 rubles.

To switch to the "Per Second" tariff plan, you can use one of the methods described below.

One of the tricks mobile operators which each subscriber encounters in the process mobile communication, this is a per-minute call rate. This calculation of minutes spent on a call is indicated in the detailed description of almost every tariff plan. Unfortunately, this behavior of companies is difficult to explain. Indeed, in an age when every person is trying to comprehend the intricacies of the economy, when every ruble counts and should be invested in a just cause, such a luxury - per-minute billing - is simply savage. In this article we will try to look at several ways to get out of the vicious circle of overpayments, we will tell you which tariffs to connect to and which companies are best to do this with.

We all periodically encounter an unexpected depletion of funds on our number balance. Indeed, short conversations can ruin a subscriber faster than one long conversation. It turns out that no matter how much you want to reduce spending on calls, from time to time the balance still turns out to be zero. And it’s all about this per-minute billing, which “eats” minutes from the package included in the subscription fee and forces you to overpay for almost every call with a standard tariff. It turns out that even if you connect a tariff from the “All Inclusive” line from MTS, Beeline or Megafon, you won’t be able to “deceive” the operator. He will still take money for services that you did not actually use. Agree, it’s a shame to pay for three minutes of conversation if you spoke for two minutes and five seconds. And it’s impossible to guess so that the conversation lasts two minutes and fifty-nine seconds. It’s a shame to throw away seconds from the paid package of minutes in the operator’s unlimited tariff. The obvious deception of the operator is difficult to justify somehow. The simplicity of calculating the services spent by a subscriber is not a suitable argument. So what should we do, ordinary subscribers who do not want to give their money to cunning operators? There are only two ways to avoid the disadvantages of per-minute billing: connect a tariff with per-second billing or unlimited tariff Communications Corporation.

The first method is offered by the operators themselves. Knowing full well that there would be quite a lot of people dissatisfied with this condition, they were created for them. special rates, allowing you to pay for exactly as many minutes as were spent. Let's look at what each operator offers so you can choose your company's plan.

Beeline offers a “Per Second” tariff for connection. The cost of one second of conversation is 5 kopecks. The first three seconds are free of charge, as in most other operator offers. Per-second billing is maintained when calling from home zone with numbers of any operators in Moscow and the Moscow region. As soon as you leave the area, outgoing call will be charged per minute. It is also worth noting that the per-second tariff ends up being more expensive. There are no exceptions for communication within the network; if you multiply 5 kopecks by 60 seconds, a minute will cost 3 rubles, which is more expensive than other Beeline offers. In the “Zero Doubts” tariff, where there is a preferential price for calls to Beeline numbers, a minute of conversation with the numbers of competing companies costs only 2 rubles 30 kopecks. And in the “All for 200” tariff, where calls within the network are generally free, a minute of conversation with Megafon and MTS numbers costs only 1 ruble 60 kopecks. It turns out that you can avoid overpaying for unspent seconds only if you make no more than three to five short calls a day. This option is suitable for those users who actively use the Internet and communicate exclusively through mobile applications.

MTS's tariff for those who want to save on seconds has a similar name. In addition, a second of conversation also costs 5 kopecks. And this is not surprising, competition in the cellular communications market literally forces companies to repeat one after another the terms of some tariffs, literally penny for penny. An SMS message here also costs 2 rubles. But at the tariff " Super MTS", which is so loved by many subscribers for its conditional unlimited communication with MTS numbers; minutes of conversation with Megafon or Beeline numbers costs only two and a half rubles. It seems as if the operator is specially creating such conditions so that paying per second for a call is not profitable.

Megafon decided to stand out and veiled per second tariff as an option. However, this is the most profitable option. Let’s take, for example, the “Everything is simple” tariff, according to which one minute of conversation costs 1 ruble 60 kopecks, regardless of which number you call. You can enable per-second billing on this tariff for free, but a minute of conversation will cost 2 rubles. However, it is 33 percent cheaper than the competition. This means that everyone who wants to pay for seconds is better off using the services of Megafon. A nice bonus on this tariff is one text message costs not 2 rubles, like competitors, but 1 ruble 90 kopecks. It is likely that very soon MTS and Beeline will change the terms of their tariffs in order to eliminate the “leakage” of subscribers from their customer base.

To make it easier to choose from new tariff plans, we tried to compare tariffs from MTS, MegaFon, Beeline, Tele2, Yota, Tinkoff Mobile and Rostelecom without a monthly fee.

Do you need tariffs without a subscription fee?

Yes, sure!No, we don't!

Comparison of tariffs from MTS, MegaFon, Beeline, Tele2, Yota, Tinkoff Mobile and Rostelecom without a monthly fee

Information updated on December 11, 2018, due to changes in the “Classic” tariff from Tele2.

Notes on the table

• * — For the “Super MTS” tariff, the cost of calls, SMS and Internet access are indicated without connecting the “All Super” option, which allows you to further reduce communication costs.
• ** — Payment for Internet traffic on the “Classic” tariff is charged in 10 MB increments, the first 10 MB. per day costs 15.00 ₽.
• **** - Yota and Tinkoff Mobile have added packages without minutes and Internet access for comparison.
• Be careful, all prices and tariff conditions are indicated for the Moscow region. Check the cost and conditions for your regions on the operator’s website.

Approximate calculation of the cost of services

Considering that tariffs without a monthly fee are signed up by people who do not use communications very often, let’s try to calculate the monthly expenses for each of the TPs from the table above.

We take as a basis for calculations:

• The volume of conversations is 5 minutes per day within the network;
• 2 SMS messages per day;
• To save more money, we don’t make long-distance calls and don’t use mobile Internet at all.

In total we get expenses per month (30 calendar days):

1. MegaFon “Go to zero”: 180 + 120 = 300 ₽. - Winner!
2. “Super MTS”: 225 + 120 = 345 ₽.
3. Beeline “Zero doubts”: 270 + 90 = 360 ₽.
4. Rostelecom “Basic”: 270 + 108 = 378 ₽.
5. Tele2 “Classic”: 300 + 90 = 390 ₽ and MegaFon “Per Second”: 270 + 120 = 390 ₽.
6. Yota: 375 + 150 = 525 ₽.
7. Beeline “Per Second”: 450 + 150 = 600 ₽.
8. Tinkoff Mobile: 435 + 174 = 609 ₽.

As a result: Even with such minimal parameters as 5 minutes of calls and 2 SMS per day, most TPs will be easier to replace with tariffs with subscription fee, of which operators offer a great variety. Except that “Super MTS” shows very “pleasant” numbers (it was 120 rubles before the changes of May 3, 2018). Now “Go to Zero” from MegaFon is becoming the conditional “leader”.

Video: Comparison of tariffs without a monthly fee with unexpected conclusions

We found a mistake! Please write about it below in the comments and we will correct it immediately so as not to mislead other readers. Thank you!

Look, analyze, choose which services you use most often, how many minutes, SMS and Internet you spend per day and select the most suitable and most advantageous tariff without a subscription fee.