Test of bookshelf Hi-Fi acoustics in the mid-price category. In search of real sound. Hi-Fi workhorses: putting together a budget system
When choosing computer acoustics, you need to immediately understand its palliative properties; the main goal when designing it is maximum ease of connection to a computer; the sound quality here can be noticeably inferior to Hi-Fi and especially Hi-End systems. However, for a computer or laptop this is not always a minus: if the built-in sound card is the sound source, then connecting a highly sensitive discrete amplifier to it will make it possible to enjoy the entire spectrum of interference instead of music (it happens that even the movement of a wireless mouse can be clearly heard). The rough built-in amplifier of computer acoustics simply will not notice this interference.
If you are interested in sound quality, then in this case you can choose a fairly high-quality kit, unless, of course, there is a desire or opportunity to assemble a “DAC + amplifier + passive speaker system” kit.
Recommendations for choosing speakers for a computer will be largely traditional: first of all, you should take into account the size and quality of the speaker cones; small-sized acoustics will not only not provide high-quality bass, but will also wear out more. At least 125 mm midrange drivers in durable MDF housings will be quite sufficient for a 2.0 system, but for the quality of the “bottom” a subwoofer will never be superfluous.
Computer acoustics have their own characteristic nuance with ease of control: almost always the amplifier is placed in one of the speakers, and the controls are also located there. Many manufacturers hide the controls on the back wall, apparently believing that the user will be able to adjust tone and volume from the sound card control panel. However, the most convenient are the kits where the controls are located “on the face” of the speaker closest to the right hand, so as not to overpay for remote controls.
A set of active acoustics, combined with a large screen, allows you to create something like a mini-cinema in your home or apartment. Modern acoustics produce very high-quality, rich sound and can operate under high loads. The speakers are installed in different parts of the apartment, saturating the room with surround sound, without loss of sound quality even over long distances. Models in the middle and premium price segment can be used not only for home, but also for professional tasks. The most common speaker system for home purposes includes five satellite speakers and one subwoofer. In another way, such a kit is called a 5.1 system.
Let's try to figure out which models turned out to be the best in our traditional rating. Acoustic sets were divided into four classes: inexpensive, mid-class, premium and super-premium. When distributing places, the following characteristics and indicators were taken into account:
- Total acoustic power;
- Dimensions and weight of speakers;
- Subwoofer power;
- Case material;
- Cost of the kit. The optimum ratio of price and quality
- Sound quality (subjective, based on user reviews).
The best inexpensive acoustics: budget up to 10,000 rubles.
3 Defender Hollywood 35
Best price
Country: China
Average price: 4,004 rub.
Rating (2018): 4.3
Third place in the ranking of the best inexpensive acoustic sets is occupied by Defender Hollywood 35. A distinctive feature is the presence of volume control separately for the subwoofer, center, front and rear, along with general control. Scope of application: premises with an area of up to 25 m2. The price is the best in the Hollywood line for these specific options. The housings of all elements are wooden, with magnetic shielding, causing a nearby TV or monitor to stop responding to interference. The package includes a cable that allows you to connect to a DVD. Controlled by both remote control and subwoofer.
In reviews, users highlight two main advantages: high sound purity and the ability to place these acoustics throughout the room. Ease of management is achieved due to the ability to control each element separately. Two types of inputs allow simultaneous connection of a player and a computer. There are only 3 shortcomings: the remote control is not strong enough, the speaker wires are short, and the elements cannot be hung on the wall.
2 Yamaha NS-P150
The most affordable acoustic set
A country: Japan (made in Indonesia)
Average price: 8,990 rub.
Rating (2018): 4.6
Second place in the top three is occupied by the Yamaha NS-P150 home passive system, consisting of 3 speakers: one for the center channel (65 Hz - 38 KHz) and 2 rear speakers (60 Hz - 38 KHz). The body is made of MDF with a mahogany or ebony finish. There are 2 types of placement possible: on a shelf and on a wall (the kit includes fasteners and screw terminals). The frequency range is sufficient for home cinema and listening to music. The best area of application is expanding the functionality of the front speakers.
Users call the Yamaha NS-P150 the best economy class passive speaker system when used for the center and rear. Users trust the brand and the optimal price-quality ratio. The best sound is in the mid and high frequencies. The advantages also include an aesthetically attractive appearance. The disadvantages are the short length of the wires, not the best sound at low frequencies and high maintenance requirements (dust is immediately visible).
1 BBK MA-970S
Best price/power ratio. The most purchased acoustics
Country: China
Average price: 9,600 rub.
Rating (2018): 4.7
First place in the ranking is occupied by BBK MA-970S, one of the most popular inexpensive acoustic sets. The original design instantly attracts attention. Single-way rear speakers are smaller than the front two-way speakers; all speakers are housed in dark wood-look MDF housings with silver-look edging. In the TOP 3, this is the most powerful speaker system, capable of delivering 280 W. The appearance of the subwoofer is simple, but consistent with the overall design. The scope of use is expanded by the presence of 2 inputs (audio 5.1CH and stereo) and a decoder that converts stereo signals into multi-channel ones. The device provides fairly good detail and richness of sound. The system is controlled using a remote control.
Buyers consider the advantages of acoustics to be the sound, which is quite sufficient for an apartment. Positive qualities are best manifested when watching films. Reviews also note decent appearance, ease of use and price-to-power ratio. The disadvantages users include is the lack of manual control, the remote control angle is too small, the short length of the included wires and the need to find additional space for placement.
The best middle-class acoustic sets: budget up to 40,000 rubles.
3 Pioneer S-ES3TB
The best ratio of price and quality
A country: Japan (made in China)
Average price: 24,500 rub.
Rating (2018): 4.6
Third place in the rating is Pioneer S-ES3TB, perhaps the best opportunity to build a home theater at minimal cost. The total power of this system is 660 W, the frequency range is from 40 to 3 thousand Hz, the power of the floor-standing front speakers is 150 W. This is not always enough for high-quality reproduction of complex musical works. Also, the absence of crossover filters and shielded magnets in the speakers makes itself felt. But, although the rating of the Pioneer S-ES3TB is relatively low, the system managed to confidently take the lead, leaving inexpensive stereo systems and box-based entertainment centers far behind.
This system has proven itself to be an inexpensive but effective component of the modern home theater when watching movies, providing expressive transmission of special effects and soundtracks. In addition, users did not ignore the excellent bass sound, sound balance, and lack of distortion. Some offer to further improve the sound quality by connecting a stereo amplifier to the Pioneer S-ES3TB, assuring that in this case the acoustics seriously benefit.
2 Onkyo SKS-HT728
Best design. Clear and transparent sound
Country: Japan
Average price: RUB 33,390.
Rating (2018): 4.8
Home acoustics set "Onkyo SKS HT728" is a device with a wide frequency range in the range from 25 to 50,000 Hz. Owners of the system can enjoy rare purity and transparency of sound. There are practically no disadvantages. Although it should still be noted that the active subwoofer (with a power of 290 W and a frequency range of 25-150 Hz) is vulnerable to significant overloads. But this nuance and the lack of a built-in amplifier only slightly affects the high rating of the device.
The power level of the stylish looking floor standing front speakers is around 520W. This is a high-quality modern acoustics that surprises with its excellent sound quality. It is worth noting the impeccable assembly. In its price category, this is perhaps the best model, fully providing an excellent level of playback, including mp3 files.
1 Bose Acoustimass 5
Best sound. Superb build quality
Country: USA
Average price: RUB 39,990
Rating (2018): 4.9
The leader in the rating of middle-class acoustic sets is the compact Bose Acoustimass 5, equipped with two small bookshelf speakers Direct/Reflecting Series II. The model has been leading the ranking of the most popular speaker systems for several years now, successfully competing with more powerful systems. This acoustics amazes with its perfection: Bose Acoustimass 5 is not inferior to similar systems in depth and purity of sound in all frequency ranges. At the same time, users note an impeccable level of build quality.
The Acoustimass module provides amazing sound richness and low-frequency power. Domestic music lovers have already noted the excellent compatibility of Bose Acoustimass 5 speakers and a subwoofer. The system is sold complete with all the necessary marked cables (4 pcs.) and fasteners, which greatly simplifies its installation. The versatility and attractive design of the speakers makes it easy to adapt the device to any interior.
Compared to its predecessor, the Acoustimass 3 model, the device differs in the greater power of the Acoustimass module and Direct/Reflecting Series II loudspeakers. At the same time, Bose Acoustimass 5 is by far the best when it comes to the need to use the system in spacious rooms.
The best premium acoustic sets: budget up to 80,000 rubles.
3 Wharfedale Obsidian 600 5.0
Optimal price. Great design
Country: UK
Average price: 54,400 rub.
Rating (2018): 4.6
An acoustic set for all sound fans who are not looking for the smallest nuances in every note played. Equally good for listening to music and watching movies. The classic “corner” design of the speakers and subwoofer will organically fit into any interior, so you don’t have to worry about “style compatibility” when purchasing.
The kit is completely passive, but there are more than enough key features. The two rear and center speakers have two playback bands - low and high frequency. But there are three of these in the rear speakers: in addition to the usual sources, they have two 125 mm speakers for playing mid-frequency sounds. According to users, the acoustic effect largely depends on the location of the speakers. If you place them with the low-frequency drivers inward, the “subwoofer effect” will be minimal (there will be a feeling of lack of deep bass). Actually, when installing speakers on the contrary, the result will be concomitant. The system has enormous potential for sound customization, which particularly sensitive consumers could not keep silent about. Willingly lends itself to fine tuning through receivers, accepts amplifiers and generally behaves friendly even towards “newbies”. As a result, an excellent set - there are not enough stars in the sky, but it fully justifies its price.
2 Jamo S 628 HCS
The best floor-standing acoustic kit
Country: Denmark
Average price: 56,990 rub.
Rating (2018): 4.6
Second place in the rating is Jamo S 628 HCS, a time-tested floor-standing audio system that has received high praise from both professionals and amateurs. A characteristic feature of acoustics is the fundamental sound, especially noticeable in the lower register. The sound quality is confirmed by technical parameters: system power (total - 390 W), wide frequency range (37-20000 Hz), sensitivity of the front speakers - 86 dB, rear radiators and the central channel - 87 dB each.
The design of the passive type system has been carefully designed. The kit includes an aluminum-coated cone that smooths out the midrange frequencies. The housings of the speakers and the central channel do not deform sound vibrations, since they are acoustically inert. The cone material quickly dissipates heat from the voice coil. For this reason, even at peak load the system demonstrates undistorted sound. The bass sounds especially beautiful - “velvety” (according to buyers).
Users note that at maximum volume, vibrations of sound waves are felt throughout the body, so not everyone uses a subwoofer. The design is a continuation of the solutions characteristic of the Danish company: elongated rectangular bodies. The sets are presented in three finishing options: white, “black ash” and “dark apple”. The device is ideal for watching movies and listening to music in studio apartments with an area of 25-30 meters.
Minor shortcomings include difficulties in selecting brackets for mounting rear speakers and the need to fine-tune the system.
1 Cabasse Eole 3
The best compact acoustic kit
Country: France
Average price: 79,000 rub.
Rating (2018): 4.8
An original set of acoustics that amazes with its dimensions and accompanying sound. Contains five round-shaped columns, of which:
- two rear speakers on a high stand with a power of 70 W each;
- two monopolar bookshelf speakers with a total power of 140 W;
- one speaker on the center channel of the same power - 70 W.
With such good total power, the speakers have a very significant advantage in compactness, which is primarily noted by users. Reproducible frequencies range from 150 to 22,000 Hz - a rather mediocre result, considering the cost of the entire set.
The active subwoofer with a power of 200 W is not without praise - it is moderately “strong” and clearly fulfills its role. It performs well in the “lower” range, reproducing frequencies with virtually no complaints (small inaccuracies can only be heard by people who are very meticulous about sound purity). According to consumers, Cabasse Eole 3 fully justifies its price tag: it is reflected in the high-quality, not devoid of creativity, the compactness of the sound-reproducing elements, and the purity of the sound itself (both when watching movies and when listening to music).
The best super premium acoustic sets
3 KEF E305
Best sound (max. frequency 45000 Hz). The most unusual design
Country: China
Average price: 88,200 rub.
Rating (2018): 4.7
The ceiling-type audio system KEF E305 standard 5.1 is the choice of innovators who are able to appreciate the naturalness of sound and the boldness of the design solution. The KEF E305 acoustics are well known: just say “eggs” or “Easter set”, and an experienced user will immediately imagine which model from the famous English company we are talking about. First place in the ranking of premium acoustic systems!
The main feature of the set is detail, volume and accuracy of sound reproduction. The Hi fi system earned the “Best Sound” rating due to its characteristics: a large frequency range (33-45000 Hz) and high sensitivity (86 dB). The device uses technologies found in premium models. For example, the Uni-Q coaxial speaker, which combines a tweeter and a mid-range driver. As a result, the user enjoys deep, harmonious sound: the system suppresses noise and smoothes out the amplitude of vibrations.
An acoustically invisible, but at the same time powerful subwoofer works for this purpose. Its low-frequency radiation does not dominate the rest of the sound field. The stiffening ribs of the satellite housings are made of noise canceling plastic. Users note that the best sound is in the mid and high range. The expressiveness of the sound is lost when the volume is reduced.
The second feature that immediately catches your eye is the unusual design: a dome-shaped subwoofer housing with a downward-facing emitter, egg-shaped emitters of a compact design. It is not difficult to strengthen the satellites on the walls. As an option, the speakers are mounted on stands (not included). A successful solution is a combination of an original design and the use of classic colors: dazzling white and deep black. The set fits organically into any design environment.
Among the manufacturer's shortcomings, consumers include a small angle of inclination of the speakers, which creates difficulties during placement and configuration.
2 Bose Acoustimass 10
The most popular set. User selection
Country: USA
Average price: 89,990 rub.
Rating (2018): 4.8
It is not for nothing that the famous American manufacturer Bose is one of the best in the production of high-quality acoustics. The tenth version of the legendary Acousticmass series turned out to be what every user who needs good sound needs. And these are far from empty words (and not absurd): the consumer finds something of his own in this amazing kit, which has become extremely popular since the fifth version.
First of all, the impressive size and weight of the subwoofer catches your eye - almost 16 kilograms of low-frequency “happiness” gives really soft and “tasty” bass. The feeling of admiration does not leave the consumer even when examining the speakers: a standard set of two rear, two front and one central sources provides a total of 250 W of pure power. This is not too much, but the first time you turn on the kit it becomes clear that more is not needed. From the very first minutes it becomes clear that Bose did a titanic job and poured in a mountain of funds and it was not in vain.
The acoustics cope perfectly with their task without additional amplifiers, come in three colors and generally look like a priority choice among their competitors.
1 Focal Pack Dome 5.1
Best Sound Quality
Country: France
Average price: RUB 139,990.
Rating (2018): 4.9
An acoustic set that can change the idea of ideal sound quality. This is the case when the huge cost is fully compensated by the highest precision of assembly, reliability and the sensation of listening to the reproduced sound. The speakers and active subwoofer have an aluminum housing, stylized in gloss, which can fit into any interior. A standard set of five speakers reproduces sound with a frequency from 80 to 28,000 Hz, so much so that even the most capricious consumers could not find any flaws (provided that the equalizer is adequately adjusted). As for the subwoofer, it operates at frequencies from 47 to 200 Hz.
It is advisable to use such a kit in a large, spacious room, and the dimensions clearly indicate this. The weight of each speaker is almost 1.9 kilograms with dimensions of 144x172x143 millimeters (width, height and depth, respectively), and the subwoofer weighs 11 kilograms. There is no hope of assembling the system at home - in a small room the sound will greatly disturb the neighbors, and it will not have the best effect on the health of listeners. The final advantage lies in the finishing options for the set - consumers can choose from sets in red, white and black. An ideal choice for large areas.
A common mistake when comparing speaker systems is to place too much emphasis on the stated frequency range. The technical specifications of many budget speakers indicate a frequency range of 20 Hz to 20 kHz or even more, although more expensive speakers may have a more modest range.
The mere ability of a speaker to reproduce certain frequencies does not mean anything. It is important how uniformly in volume and with what distortions sounds at different frequencies will be reproduced, compared to the signal they received at the input. Therefore, if you really want to understand what frequencies and how exactly a particular speaker system can reproduce, look for its amplitude-frequency response (AFC) - a graph that shows how correctly (quieter or louder compared to the input signal) ) certain frequencies are reproduced.
There are many different acoustic systems produced in the world, and each of them has its own “sound signature”. And it’s not just a matter of frequency response; there are other important parameters. Unfortunately, it is impossible to write in simple words or summarize in a clear and small table a description of the sound of a particular speaker. But you can give some useful tips.
When choosing speaker systems, you must first of all be guided by the parameters of the room in which the speaker systems will be installed, and the recommended amplifier power in combination with the specified impedance. Be sure to check the minimum acoustic impedance level allowed for your amplifier.
If you want to clarify how loud a particular speaker system can produce, pay attention to the “sensitivity” parameter. It shows what sound pressure (in dB) the system produces from a distance of 1 m with an input power of 1 W. Doubling the power will result in a 3 dB increase in sound pressure. For example, if the acoustics have a sensitivity of 88 dB/W/m, then when applying a power of 4 W we will get a sound pressure of 94 dB at a distance of 1 m. Some manufacturers list sensitivity based on a 2.83V applied voltage rather than 1W power. In this case, for comparison, 3 dB should be subtracted from the indicated number.
Finally, it is recommended to listen to the selected speakers yourself. Fortunately, listening rooms in specialized stores are not uncommon. If this is not possible, try to find the most detailed review that tells you exactly how this acoustic system sounds. Even better if this is a comparison of several models of the same class.
When listening, it is advisable to use equipment that is as close in parameters as possible to what you have at home - the same class and preferably the same manufacturer, and it is also important that the listening takes place in a similar room. All speakers sound different when used with different equipment. To the audition, bring with you the music that you usually listen to and know well. This is the only way you can find exactly “your” speakers.
Let's imagine a person who is interested in music, but has never paid attention to sound quality. And so, having heard a lot about Hi-Fi and High-End technology, he decides to check for himself what “real sound” is. As a rule, he doesn’t have much money, and it’s a pity to spend it on what he doesn’t yet know. Our test of bookshelf speakers will be very useful for just such a person, and it is in this price range that you can find speakers that can demonstrate true Hi-Fi sound quality. Yes, you will have to make a small allowance for the bass depth. But, on the other hand, bookshelf acoustics, as a rule, play better at low volumes than floor-standing ones, and it will be easier to place them in the room. A dozen speakers - a wide choice. I am sure that among them there will be very, very worthy specimens.
Criteria for evaluation
We are dealing with classic workhorses, and the approach to testing is quite traditional. The frequency response and SOI will show us how flawlessly the speaker design is made from a technical point of view. Together with the design features of the model, this will constitute a design assessment.
Listening will make its own adjustments and will reveal the sound character of the speakers. Good bass depth and high quality are rarely combined in the bookshelf format, so we won’t be too strict about this parameter. But having a clean and even upper register is quite possible for small speakers. The importance of this parameter is extremely important for the natural presentation of musical material. High-quality sound at low volumes is also important and is an indicator of smooth, almost linear speaker dynamics. Timbral fidelity will allow you to enjoy the full beauty of the sound of each individual instrument. After all, musical instruments are created in order to enjoy their sound, and not to try to understand what exactly is playing. All this will add up to a sound rating. The last assessment is inversely proportional to the price: higher the price - lower the assessment.
Acoustic Energy 301
Sound: 4Construction: 4
Price: 4
Advantages:
- High detail
- Timbral fidelity
Flaws:
- Not enough air
When developing the 300 series, the designers achieved visual minimalism. All small details such as screws and grill mounts are excluded from the appearance. The front wall of the speaker is finished with a black rubber-like coating, merging in color with the diffusers of the emitters. The finishing of the speakers is also minimalistic - black or white varnish. Model 301 houses a proprietary 28 mm fabric dome tweeter and a traditional, well-recognized midrange/bass driver with a cone made of bent, heavily anodized aluminum with a diameter of 110 mm. This speaker is a distant legacy of the legendary AE1 monitors.
Bookshelf acoustics Acoustic Energy 301 It is curious that the company decided to use a slotted bass reflex port located on the front panel. It was possible to save the size of the column while conveniently placing it near the wall.
Sound
The absence of any noticeable sound color allows the speaker to unfold and, even when playing rather restrainedly, present musical compositions in an interesting way. The smallest details are clearly visible, and the timbres are very close to natural. The entire frequency scale is well balanced both in level and dynamics - the sound is holistic.
Upper register intelligibility is not bad, but it is a little lacking for an open sound with enough air. On complex compositions, the intelligibility of musical material decreases. At low volumes the sound character remains almost unchanged.
Measurements
The frequency response is very smooth. The decline in the low-frequency region is uniform. Bass is medium deep. The THD is quite low right down to the very bottom and is practically independent of the volume level. Impedance is unstable.
Bowers & Wilkins 685
Sound: 4
Construction: 5
Price: 5
Advantages:
- Spacious sound
- Fast bass
Flaws:
- Slight simplification of timbres
The model represents the junior line of Bowers & Wilkins. Possessing a laconic modern design, the line nevertheless inherited some technologies from the flagships themselves. Of course, this only applies to inexpensive and effective solutions such as Nautilus tweeter tubes, Kevlar cones and a golf ball bass reflex port. The aluminum dome tweeter is surrounded by a special material that helps achieve spacious sound. The midrange/woofer uses a static bullet to smooth out the response at the upper end of frequencies.
Bookshelf speakers Bowers & Wilkins 685 The crossover of the model is minimized as much as possible - it is of the first order. The speaker body is finished with film, and the front panel is covered with a velvety material that is pleasant to the touch.
Sound
The sound of the model is open and bright. Detail is at a good level. The bass is collected and fast. Localization is clear. Impressive dynamic range.
Instrument timbres are slightly simplified at mid frequencies. In this case, the upper register region is very active.
It adds airiness and spaciousness to the sound. The model is characterized by increased emotionality and expressiveness.
Measurements
There are noticeable irregularities in the region of 2.5 kHz and 6-7 kHz, which disappear when the speaker is rotated 30°. However, the frequency balance shifts slightly to the low-frequency region. SOI is extremely low. The impedance is extremely unstable.
Canton Chrono 503.2
Sound: 4
Construction: 5
Price: 5
Advantages:
- Clean upper case
- Accurate reproduction of timbres
Flaws:
- Bass is weak at low volumes
Chrono 503.2 is a real German speaker: excellent workmanship, 100% quality control of each copy, Made in Germany. Despite the stated glossy finish, the speaker is covered with film, and only the front panel is made glossy. The size of the speaker is not very large, but the speaker managed to accommodate an impressive 180 mm. Of course, it is equipped with the traditional Canton aluminum diffuser. The suspension is made in the shape of a wave for the most linear and long piston stroke of the diffuser. The 25mm tweeter dome is made from a very lightweight but durable aluminum and magnesium alloy. For reliability, it is protected by a metal grill. There are two threaded holes on the bottom for mounting on a stand or bracket.
Bookshelf speakers Canton Chrono 503.2 
Sound
The musical material is presented very carefully. The frequency balance is almost perfect. The timbres of instruments are transmitted with high reliability, and small details are not lost sight of. There is no increased emotionality, but thanks to a wide and smooth dynamic range, the speakers manage to accurately convey the musical idea of the composition. The bass is collected, neat, exactly in its place. However, it is not very deep, and at low volumes it loses its position even more. At first it seems that there are too many high frequencies, but they appear exactly when you really need them, and in the right quantities. The upper register is very clean, which fans of modern electronic music will certainly appreciate.
Measurements
The frequency response is smooth, although it depends quite strongly on the listening angle - the directivity of the speakers is relatively narrow. The THD is very low and there is good headroom at low frequencies. Impedance is unstable.
Chario Syntar 516
Sound: 3
Construction: 4
Price: 4
Advantages:
- Emotional presentation
- Clear localization
Flaws:
- Simplification of timbres
The Italian speaker is made in the most classic design with veneer finishing. Before sawing out the walls of the body, HDF slabs are finished on both sides with natural wood. This makes the speaker more durable. The assembly and further processing of the case is carried out manually by specialists in Italy. Finished specimens are carefully tested to ensure compliance with the required acoustic parameters. The Silversoft Neodium model's tweeter uses a special membrane coated with aluminum powder, just like in the company's top-line speakers. It is interesting that a significant part of the mid-range is also devoted to the tweeter - starting from 1 kHz. The shape of the midrange/bass speaker diffuser, double curved, was selected by the designers specifically taking into account psychoacoustics and over the course of months of research.
Bookshelf speakers Chario Syntar 516 The bass reflex port ends in a simple hole cut asymmetrically into the bottom. High rubber feet on the bottom of the case allow the port to work quite efficiently.
Sound
The sound of the speakers is, on the one hand, soft and unhurried, and on the other, a very clear, active upper register. The timbre picture is slightly blurred, the smallest details are veiled. And yet the speakers manage to quite accurately and emotionally convey the mood of musical compositions. The bass is quite deep and slightly dominant in the overall sound picture. With good localization, the music scene lacks clarity and transparency. This is more noticeable on complex compositions. At low volumes the bass weakens, but the sound remains quite dynamic and emotional.
Measurements
The best frequency response is observed at a listening angle of 30°. The unevenness is relatively good, with an even roll-off in the low frequencies. SOI is quite good down to the lowest frequencies. The impedance is relatively stable.
Dynaudio DM 2/7
Sound: 5
Construction: 5
Price: 5
Advantages:
- Timbral fidelity
- Clean upper case
Flaws:
- Strictness in presentation
The DM line is the entry-level acoustics in terms of the famous Danish company Dynaudio. The column is designed in a completely recognizable style of this company. The gray front panel is specially made thicker to effectively dampen chassis resonances. The body itself is also carefully sealed and finished with high quality traditional veneer. The branded tweeter is equipped with a 28 mm dome made of textile impregnated with a special compound. The diffuser of the midrange/woofer speaker is stamped from the already well-proven magnesium silicate polymer. The driver voice coils are wound on a Kapton base with lightweight aluminum wire. Together with powerful magnetic systems, this allows for remarkable dynamics and sensitivity.
Bookshelf speakers Dynaudio DM 2/7 Particular attention is paid to maximum impedance linearity to minimize speaker dependence on the amplifier.
Sound
The presentation of musical material by the speaker is relaxed and natural. Excellent tonal resolution makes the sound stage very believable. The spatial placement of instruments is clearly visible.
The bass is tight and well-developed. The upper register is clear and pleasant to the ear. The sound is highly detailed and lacks coloration. At low volumes the speakers play just as confidently as at high volumes.
Measurements
The frequency response is elongated into a very even strip with a barely noticeable skew towards high frequencies. The focus is broad. THD is low and stable. The impedance is quite stable. Exemplary results.
Magnat Quantum 753
Sound: 5
Construction: 4
Price: 4
Advantages:
- Timbre accuracy
- Clean music scene
Flaws:
- Slightly sparse sound
The speaker from Magnat's mid-priced Quantum 750 line looks solid. The front wall is made thick (40 mm) to radically combat body resonances. A solid 30 mm thick podium also emphasizes the solidity of the structure. It is curious that the front panel and podium are polished to a shine, while the rest of the surface of the case is matte. The F-max tweeter is equipped with a dome made of a double textile compound and has an extended operating frequency range. The midrange/bass speaker diffuser is made of ceramic/aluminium. The voice coil is well ventilated. The aluminum speaker basket design is optimized for optimal airflow and reduced resonances.
Bookshelf speakers Magnat Quantum 753 The bass reflex port with a large horn is located on the rear wall. The crossover is optimized for signal phase and amplitude and is assembled from selected high-quality elements.
Sound
The speakers play emotionally, dynamically, quickly. At the same time, the timbres of instruments are perfectly conveyed, and the musical scene is not obscured by extraneous sounds - they are pure and deep. Sound source localization is excellent. The detailing is also at a high level.
The HF level is enough for an open sound with the presence of airiness, and at the same time the upper register is very neat and unobtrusive.
Bass of medium depth, collected and fast. There is a little lack of physicality and density of presentation. At low volumes, the enthusiasm of the speakers is lost, the emotionality fades.
Measurements
The unevenness of the frequency response is minimal, but the frequency imbalance towards the HF is obvious. The SOI varies within 1% and noticeably depends on the volume, but no obvious resonances are noted. Good SOI margin at low frequencies. Impedance is unstable.
Martin Logan Motion 15
Sound: 4
Construction: 4
Price: 3
Advantages:
- Energetic delivery
- Fast and tight bass
Flaws:
- Weak at low volumes
The speakers are eye-catching with their stunning natural finish and attractive black steel grille. The housing cover is slightly tilted back. Under the grille is another surprise - a ribbon tweeter (a sign of an expensive device). The front panel of the speaker is made of black anodized aluminum. The diffuser of the long-throw midrange/woofer speaker is also made of black anodized aluminum to match the panel. The emitters are matched through a crossover with an improved topology, assembled using polypropylene capacitors and low-loss electrolytes, as well as hand-wound inductors.
Bookshelf speakers Martin Logan Motion 15 The circuit provides thermal and current protection. The bass reflex port is located on the rear wall. The speaker body is assembled from 19 mm thick MDF boards.
Sound
The peculiarity of the speakers is that they do not like to play at low and medium volumes. In this mode of operation, only the midrange remains of the frequency range, and the dynamics become inexpressive.
As the volume increases, fast, elastic bass and fairly detailed highs appear. However, the lower middle still continues to prevail. The presentation of the musical material is scathing. At the same time, we must pay tribute, no extraneous overtones are felt; on the contrary, after-sounds sometimes disappear even where they should be.
The model tends to simplify the instrument timbres a little. At the same time, the ribbon tweeter is very audible, which gives a characteristic delicate color to the mid-high range.
Measurements
Uneven frequency response in the HF region is noticeable. The decrease in sensitivity towards the low frequencies is quite sharp. The focus is broad. The SOI has slight rises in the midrange, but nevertheless remains below 1%. The impedance is relatively stable.
MK Sound LCR 750
Sound: 5
Construction: 5
Price: 4
Advantages:
- Focused sound
- Good tonal resolution
Flaws:
- Do not hide the shortcomings of the recording
All acoustic systems of the American company M&K Sound are made in black without any embellishment. And the main decoration of the products is compliance with the highest standards of sound reproduction. Series 750 is a compact set of speakers for creating a home theater. And the largest speaker in the series (not counting the subwoofer) is the 750 LCR model. The speaker is quite unusual, especially in our test. Firstly, the closed acoustic design reduces bass response. Secondly, the use of two midrange/woofer speakers at once significantly expands the dynamic range of the speaker. Third, the tweeter panel being rotated 4.7° away from the listener likely increases and/or equalizes the dispersion of various frequencies. The tweeter dome is made of silk coated with polymer.
Bookshelf speakers MK Sound LCR 750 
The speaker diffusers are polypropylene, with mineral filler. Of particular note is the Phase-Focused crossover, which significantly improves almost all speaker parameters. The back wall has many threaded holes for different speaker mounting options.
Sound
Excellent control of musical material. The sound is almost monitor-like, smooth. All instruments are clearly visible: they are clearly defined both spatially and timbre. Nothing unnecessary interferes with the overall musical picture; all the nuances are heard clearly. And since there is no emotional coloring, the sound of the speakers is not as exciting as that of many other models, and depends entirely on the musical composition itself.
Measurements
Irregularities in the frequency response of the column are insignificant. A rotation of 30° gives the best results. The THD is very low and increases very smoothly towards low frequencies, exceeding 5% only at low volumes. The impedance is quite stable. Very worthy results.
PSB Imagine B
Sound: 5
Construction: 5
Price: 3
Advantages:
- Natural transmission of timbres
- Smooth dynamics
Flaws:
- HF area limited
The Canadian company PSB has been offering the Imagine line for several years. During this time, she managed to earn a Red Dot award for design and a lot of positive reviews from various experts. The column body is a geometric intersection of several elliptical cylinders. All walls are curved. And this creates a feeling of solidity and strength of the structure. The 25 mm tweeter also looks solid - a dome made of durable titanium, the coil is cooled by magnetic fluid, and a powerful neodymium magnet. The midrange/bass speaker diffuser is made of polypropylene with clay-ceramic filler (mineral). The bass reflex port is located on the rear side. The column is finished with high quality natural veneer.
Bookshelf speakers PSB Imagine B 
Sound
The sound is collected and well balanced in frequency. Excellent localization and natural transmission of timbres make the musical scene almost real, alive. Smooth dynamics allow the speakers to play naturally and freely even at low volumes. Musical matter is pure. The high-frequency range is slightly limited, due to which the airiness is partially lost, turning into intimacy.
Speakers can miss the smallest details, but at the same time maintain expressiveness and richness of sound. The bass, although not deep, is very well designed. The mid frequencies are also quite good, timbre rich and quite correct.
Measurements
A very flat frequency response measured along the acoustic axis. Turning the speakers away from the listener is undesirable - they begin to lose treble frequencies. SOI is stable and low down to the lower frequency limit. Impedance is stable.
Rega RS1
Sound: 5
Construction: 4
Price: 4
Advantages:
- Clean upper case
- Wide dynamic range
Flaws:
- Slight sound color
The English company Rega has developed and offers customers the only series of RS speakers. The purpose of their creation is to harmoniously complement other sound equipment also developed within the walls of Rega. However, speakers are available to buyers separately from this equipment. The RS1 model is quite compact and, judging by its weight, is assembled from thin MDF. Despite this, the performance of the speakers is top notch, with neat veneer finishing and a strict design. The drivers are designed by Rega engineers and hand-assembled in-house. The 19mm tweeter features a specially shaped rear chamber to better dampen sound waves from the back of the tweeter dome. Mid/bass speaker with paper diffuser.
Bookshelf speakers Rega RS1 The smooth frequency response of the speaker makes it easy to integrate it with a tweeter using a simple crossover with good phase locking. The bass reflex port is located on the rear wall.
Sound
The speakers reproduce timbres quite accurately, but due to the slight coloration, the music scene becomes a little less transparent. The upper register is missing quite a bit, but it is very clean. The details are present, but slightly veiled. Musical material is presented in a sweeping, open manner
The bass is quite accurate, but sometimes lacks weight. The localization of sound sources is somewhat blurred.
The speaker handles complex music somewhat worse - the intelligibility of the sound material decreases. However, at low volumes the speakers play very convincingly.
Measurements
Irregularities in the frequency response in the upper middle and high frequencies form the special character of the sound of the speakers. The speakers play more smoothly if they are rotated 30°. The SOI is unstable, but quite low, less than 1%. The impedance is extremely unstable.
Triangle Color Bookshelf
Sound: 5
Construction: 4
Price: 5
Advantages:
- Open live sound
- Accurate reproduction of timbres
Flaws:
- Slight excess bass
Very nice-looking speakers from the French manufacturer Triangle are available in three lacquer colors - white, black and red. The Color line stands out with its bright, cheerful style among all Triangle products and takes its place as the entry-level line.
The bookshelf model uses a tweeter with a titanium membrane and a midrange/woofer with a paper cone. In general, the speaker is quite interesting; its suspension is wide, corrugated and basically made of fabric. The paper diffuser is coated with a special compound. The dust cap is designed in the shape of a bullet. The design of the crossover uses developments from the top Magellan line. The bass reflex port is located on the rear wall of the speaker.
Bookshelf acoustics Triangle Color Bookshelf 
Sound
The sound of the model is very lively and natural. Timbral fidelity is very high. The presentation of sound material is natural and relaxed.
The dynamics surprisingly accurately replicate a live performance. The bass is deep and beautifully defined. Sometimes it even seems like there is too much of it.
The musical matter is very pure and extremely detailed. No nuances escape the speakers' field of view.
They cope with compositions of any complexity. The sound quality is not lost even at low volumes.
Measurements
The imbalance of the frequency response towards the HF is obvious. It is treated as usual - turning the AC by 30°. The SOI is quite low, although in the midrange it is noticeably higher, but remains within 1%. High volume causes slightly more distortion in the upper bass. Impedance is unstable.
Wharfedale Jade 3
Sound: 5
Construction: 5
Price: 4
Advantages:
- Good detail
- Clear localization
Flaws:
- Slightly weakened dynamics
The British company Wharfedale traditionally spares neither effort nor materials even on budget lines. And the Jade 3 model once again confirms this. In our test, this is the largest and heaviest shelf speaker, and the only 3-way one. A body with curved walls is a feature of the top lines of many other manufacturers, but not Wharfedale. Both the body shape and the additional bulkheads make the body as acoustically inert as possible, preventing unwanted sound coloration. High frequencies are handled by an aluminum dome tweeter. At the border of 3 kHz it is replaced by a midrange speaker with a diffuser made of aluminum-cellulose composite. And already in the region of 350 Hz, the initiative is seized by the woofer, equipped with a woven diffuser made of a mixture of carbon and fiberglass. The combination of such materials with a braided structure brings the diffuser closer to an ideal piston, eliminating the problematic resonance phenomena inherent in metal diffusers.
Bookshelf speakers Wharfedale Jade 3 The speakers operate in a closed volume. The crossover for the speaker was optimized on a computer for maximum linearity of signal phase transmission.
Sound
Wharfedale speakers sound traditionally beautiful. All instruments are clearly arranged spatially. The music stage is clean and spacious.
The speakers deliver bass carefully, not forcefully, as if they are afraid of damaging the balance of the overall sound picture. The same can be said about uppercase.
The softness of the presentation of musical material is interestingly and harmoniously combined with excellent sound detail. In addition, the speakers play very well at low volumes.
Measurements
The frequency response of the model is flat, but at high frequencies it behaves peculiarly - a decline and a sharp rise. The bass is deep. The SOI is almost perfectly flat and extremely low. Very solid headroom for low frequencies. The impedance is quite stable.
conclusions
It should be noted that it is becoming less and less interesting to study the results of speaker measurements in our test laboratory. Almost all models showed a remarkably flat frequency response and a very low THD even in the bass region! This is explained by the fact that almost all companies have already adopted computer modeling tools, with the help of which you can make, perhaps, anything sound, which, for example, the company Boston Acoustics has proven to us more than once. Even the shape of the body no longer plays such a significant role; the main thing is to correctly calculate the damping elements. Therefore, the design ratings for all models are either good or excellent.
Two models from our test deserve special mention. These are MK Sound LCR 750 and Dynaudio DM 2/7. The companies that created them were initially focused on developing professional acoustics and pursue this line even in their youngest lines. The basic principle is maximum accuracy in transmitting musical material. And no decorations. These two models fully meet this principle and, in fact, represent professional-level monitor acoustics, with all its advantages and disadvantages. Not all listeners may like the sound, or more precisely, the neutrality of the sound. This is a product for special music connoisseurs or even for a home studio. Both models are worthy of the sympathy prize.
Almost all companies have already adopted computer modeling tools, with the help of which you can make, perhaps, anything sound.
If we talk about beautiful and comfortable sound, then many of the speakers in our test successfully coped with this task. Accurate transmission of timbres, precise localization, accurate bass - all this is inherent in almost all speakers tested. The only difference is in the nature of the sound. And here the choice turned out to be rich: in the test you can find a dense, rich sound (PSB Imagine B), and an impressively sophisticated sound (Wharfedale Jade 3), and a collected, neat presentation of material (Canton Chrono 503.2), and an open airy image (Rega RS1, B&W 685), and even defiantly aggressive pressure (Martin Logan Motion 15). However, most of all I would like to highlight the French columns Triangle Color Bookshelf. They turn almost any musical material into a celebration of sound. The speakers know how to not miss the main idea of the work and at the same time present the material very beautifully, lively and dynamically. They are very pleasant and interesting to listen to. The Triangle Color Bookshelf model takes the title of test winner.
Almost everyone talked about the sound industry in the eighties of the last century. However, today this topic is discussed quite rarely. Publications about it can only be found in some specialized publications. But many of us are not even aware of the possibilities that modern audio technologies can provide.
Entertainment systems
For every person, home is a place where, after a hard day at work, he can relax by spending time reading books or watching TV. For many of us, it is no less pleasant to listen to our favorite music or enjoy watching a movie.
In order to get a complete feeling of comfort, you will need a good sound system. Of course, any technology has built-in speakers. However, they are usually of low quality. This is why many people seek to purchase additional devices for audio output. What are the best
Requirement Criteria
How to choose a speaker system for home use? First of all, you need to decide why it is needed. Of course, good for a sensitive music lover and for an ordinary housewife is far from being an equivalent concept. After all, their needs are fundamentally different from each other.
In addition, you will need to make a realistic assessment of the capabilities of the premises. Even if it’s good, but with high power, it’s unlikely to be suitable for a small room of nine square meters.
That is why choosing speakers for your home is not an easy task. And when solving this issue, you will need to proceed not only from the parameters of the equipment that reproduces sound, but also from its key features. Don’t forget about your own preferences, as well as your personal financial capabilities.
Acoustic strips
Sound reproduction systems are divided into five groups. The first of them includes single-way acoustics, the second - two-way, etc. How to choose based on this parameter? For people who do not have any special needs or are simply deprived of an ear for music, it is quite enough to purchase a single-way system. All sounds from such speakers are emitted from only one speaker.
The best system is considered to be two-way. In it, one of the speakers reproduces sounds of mid and low frequencies, and the second - high frequencies. This is a good speaker system for watching movies or listening to music, as it delivers deep bass separately. This uses a subwoofer. This is a speaker that reproduces the low-frequency range of sound frequencies. It has a fairly powerful speaker built into it.
Good for people with more refined musical taste - three-band. In it, high, mid and low frequencies are reproduced in separate speakers. This system allows you to hear smoother sound and more intelligible speech.
Power
How to select speakers based on this parameter? Some buyers believe that the most powerful speakers allow for maximum volume. However, it is not. The power of the acoustics does not at all indicate the strength of the sound it produces.
This parameter indicates the mechanical reliability of the system. The higher it is, the more durable the speakers will be. When choosing acoustics, one nuance should be taken into account. It will be of better quality when the power of the speakers is higher than the same amplifier parameter.
Active and passive
The loudspeaker systems available on the market are divided into two types. The first one is active. In such a system, the amplifier is located in the speaker. In the passive type it is located separately.
With an amplifier, you simply plug it into a power outlet. At the same time, they immediately begin to produce sounds. Passive systems will not work this way. In order to hear sound from such speakers, you will need to connect an amplifier. Simply put, active speakers work like regular computer speakers. The passive system is similar in its operating principle to headphones that are not plugged into an outlet.
Speaker systems with active amplifiers have a big advantage. It lies in the ease of use. In this regard, the entire system is quite mobile. It is easy to put it in another place or unmount it. Another advantage of active acoustics is that each of its bands, that is, the speaker, has a separate amplifier, at the output of which there are separation filters. They are also active. This filter is easy to adjust. And this allows you to get high-quality sound.
An important criterion when choosing is the wider frequency range of the active system, as well as the presence of a volume control on the speakers, which is very convenient during operation.
The second type of system also has some advantages. First of all, they lie in their relatively low cost. At the same time, passive systems, as a rule, are more powerful than active ones, and they can always be combined with an amplifier available in the house. In addition, such speakers do not need to be supplied with a linear signal and voltage.
Sensitivity
A good speaker system, capable of reproducing the loudest sounds, has high sensitivity. This indicator is measured in decibels. Their number determines the sound pressure that the speakers are capable of exerting on the surrounding space. The higher the sensitivity value, the louder the sound. Speakers with this value equal to 85 decibels are perfect for home use.
Frequency
This parameter is also important for those who are interested in a good speaker system. A person is able to hear only those sounds that are in a certain range. It ranges from 20 to 20,000 Hertz. In this case, the frequencies are distributed as follows:
Low, ranging from 10 to 200 Hertz;
- medium - from 200 to 5000 Hertz;
- high - from 5000 to 20000 Hz.
An acoustic system purchased for a home theater may have a frequency in the range of 100-20,000 Hertz. Speakers with a wide spacing are recommended for music lovers. The best for them will be speaker systems with frequencies from 20 to 35,000 Hz.
Type of shell
You should also pay attention to this parameter when choosing a speaker system. The most popular are closed-type and bass-reflex speakers. The body of the first of them is the simplest. It can have a variety of designs and satisfy the tastes of various categories of customers.
However, in a closed space, the lower resonance frequency increases significantly. This negatively affects the transmission of low frequencies. In this regard, most acoustic systems use a bass-reflex type housing.
It is an open box with perfectly selected dimensions. There is a vent in the cabinet that directs sound from the back of the speakers to the front. This allows you to significantly enhance the bass volume.
Material
On sale you can find speakers made of plastic, wood and chipboard. Each of these materials has its own advantages. Thus, plastic allows you to implement the most daring design solutions. It is quite cheap and light. However, the sounds reproduced by such speakers are much simpler. This is due to plastic rattling at high frequencies. Such speakers usually find their use when using a computer. They are not suitable for watching movies. In such cases, the best option is an acoustic system made in a wooden case.
For those who have opted for plastic, it is recommended to select speakers without sharp corners, edges and wide panels, as well as having a high-quality, reliable assembly.
Formats
For a small room, ceiling speakers are suitable. They are quite compact, have a low cost and provide good sound. Their main disadvantage is shallow bass. In addition, ceiling speakers have low sensitivity. To reproduce loud sound you only need 40 watts of power.
Good for the hall - rack-mounted. It is larger in size than the ceiling one, but at the same time provides sufficient depth of low frequencies.
Very convincing bass sounds thanks to floor-standing speakers. It's also a great hall speaker system that can shake the floor of the room. These speakers produce good sound and do not require a super powerful amplifier.
However, the size of the speakers is the main reason why they need to be anchored to the floor to eliminate additional cabinet vibrations. In addition, when such speakers are moved away from the walls for better sound, the space they occupy increases significantly. Such acoustic systems can be quite massive and attract attention. And their cost is not so small.
Professional equipment
According to some lovers of good music, such audio systems are of the highest quality. However, in reality everything is different. Professional acoustic systems do not get their name from their advantageous differences in certain parameters. They are simply used to carry out activities related to sound reproduction.
Professional acoustic systems do not have any design frills, and expensive materials are not used in their production. Their main difference from amateur speakers is the use of certain elements that can withstand constant load. After all, such systems operate in stores or fitness clubs constantly, during the entire working time. In addition, professional speakers have great power. It is this that allows them to voice a fairly vast space.
Manufacturers
Those who want to purchase the best speaker system and have sufficient funds should consider the equipment of those manufacturers who are leaders in the sound reproduction equipment market. And first of all, I would like to say about the company Bowers & Wilkins (B&W). It rightfully occupies one of the first places in the list of the best manufacturers of speaker systems. The company specializes in producing the most advanced home theater systems. At the same time, she offers her clients only the best acoustics that perfectly reproduce any music. Such systems are not cheap. However, with their help you can hear almost perfect sound.
The ranking of the best manufacturers continues with Rotel equipment. It originated as a small family business, and today it is a reputable company that professionally deals with audio equipment. Reviews from consumers who bought its equipment for home use confirm the high quality of the devices. In addition, the company produces audio systems that are suitable for buyers with different income levels.
Yamaha offers affordable and high-quality speakers. This Japanese manufacturer knows a lot more than just speaker systems. Some branches of the company also produce classical and other musical instruments, which are highly valued by consumers all over the world.
Jamo audio equipment is also well known to many users. The speakers it produces are of high quality and are in different price categories.
Brands such as JBL, Magnat, Dali and HECO also produce products that are worthy of their sound.
