The topic is actually not mine. I wouldn’t even tell all the people about, for example, my cooking of cabbage soup if I’m a complete zero in cooking! So that no one accidentally gets poisoned...

Did I say that the scheme (both) is bad??? I just said that it (them) should not be used for car headlights.
I spoke out after I saw another assessment of the “work of smooth switching on of headlights” by a person who, to put it mildly, was deceived. (Nowadays it is generally not considered shameful to lie, steal, rob, kill - the excuse is: “this is the time.”)

So.
You provided a link to a forum where someone “made a device” according to the second (of the ones discussed here) scheme. After some time, he assessed its “work”: “...I think that when using high-glow lamps, this smooth ignition will extend its service life by no more than 30-40 percent, because after ignition the lamp operates in normal mode ..." Before this message, he spoke a couple of times: "...Maxim! I called Andrey! He is now installing transistors on radiators, because at 14.2-14.3 V they heat up like a child. He makes a separate block for each headlight, two headlights at once, one block can’t stand it. Something like this....” and “...The lamp flares up in 1-1.5 seconds and it’s visually difficult to catch this moment...” That is, it was easy for the “master” to scratch his tongue, but it DIDN’T work out to make a normally working device! The lamp flares up not only in 1 second, but in 0.2 seconds - very noticeable!!! (What was done can be seen very well: in the “second circuit” only the transistor IRF4905 and resistor R2 were left (see diagram). That is, a simple SWITCH was made on the transistor! Because even the slightest delay in opening the transistor leads to a strong Such a product cannot be heated and given to the customer who paid for the work (if it’s free, or “post the diagram on the internet” - then you can!).

What I would suggest (it’s clear that putting on the Internet a diagram and a program that was not created for free (talking about money, of course, is a waste, but which of you, us, does not work for a salary???), I’m not entirely comfortable , but I don’t want to spew nonsense about making piston bulbs and other electronic components at home):
1. The link http://silich.ru/drl-free.html has already appeared here. The circuit uses a power smart switch BTS555, which has both a driver and current protection - the device is worthy of consideration. PWM control of the power switch here is provided by the processor. The circuits of such devices produced by serious companies are much more complex (I’m not talking about scammers and Ketais - everything is quite simple for them).
2. So that the “assessments” that I mentioned at the beginning do not appear, maybe it makes sense not to engage in the production of what there is no understanding of? And don’t fall for “masters” who are ready to make anything “for beer” - even make any electronic unit, even sing an aria from an opera...
3. Let me remind you of an old joke about opera:
- I heard this Pavarotti - so, some kind of bullshit.
- And where did you hear him?
- That’s what Rabinovich sang to me.